I highly disagree those other guys are not filler. They are A + musicians ...John Tom wrote:I agree about Daru. I would say that the best band would be nothing more than Jack + Daru or Jack + Daru + Dominic. Lillie Mae and Ikey and the rest are filler in many ways.UniformRecon wrote:I guess I kind of agree with you in that she's the weakest link, along with whoever is playing piano/acoustic guitar. I don't think they capture the energy of Jack's performances that the other members capture. When I see Daru having the time of his life, I love it, but Lillie Mae doesn't seem like she's really into it at all.
I agree that Lillie's voice is much better compared to Blunderbuss and that she can look a little lost on stage; especially when Jack and Daru get going, but I humbly disagree that the current band is perfect. I would wager that most Swirlers would gladly return to the minimalist days of The White Stripes and the only way for Jack to be as good as he was then is to return to a more minimalist band of guitar and drums (and bass since Dominic is so good).Alabama Woody wrote:I love the piano player ! They are all very top notch at what they do. Lillie Mae is the weakest link, but not weak by any means, just compared to who is surrounding Her.
Her voice is much better this tour. I think she has been practicing. Let's face it Jack likes having a Girl around. Who can blame him.
The band is the most talented band I think Jack has had. I liked the girl/boy tour thing for one go, I think it's probably a little much to manage. I think the current band is perfect.
After seeing Ms Mae singing with Jack on Fallon I should probably take back my weak link remark. She sounds really good with Jack. She is a great fiddle player.
The White Stripes broke up. Those days are over. Jack likes having a band, you know last tour he had 2 of them.
I love the Jack White solo stuff. If it's not edgy enough for you after you see him live then you just need to go hard core punk.
We all have different opinions but y'all have to let go of the white stripes, Jack has.